I Paid: $5.00 for both (2/$6.00 on sale, + $1.00 off coupon, at Giant)
Description: Halloween Oreo, 5 Boo-rific shapes, Same great taste; Peanut Butter Oreo
Oreos were never my favorite snack growing up- probably because we never really had them in our house. Every once in a while I'd want them and buy a snack-pack of Oreos in high school or at the supermarket. Nowadays though, it's warped into a full-on obsession for me. I "had" to get these non-traditional Oreos to try them out, for the sake of blogging- riiiiiiiiight.
First, the Halloween Oreos. This won't be so much of a review since the basic Oreo taste is there- just orange coloring in the cream and different patterns on the cookies. So they obviously taste great, if you like regular Oreos to begin with, haha. I think these would be a fun variation to use for recipes that include Oreos, to switch up the color a little.
Secondly, we have the Peanut Butter Oreos. These were a little surprising based on what I assumed they would taste like. I figured it was going to be the same cream filling, with a slight peanut butter taste to them. These were more like, full-on peanut butter paste, Nutter Butter style. Since they're both made by Nabisco, I wouldn't be too surprised if they just used the Nutter Butter filling for these Oreos. I think these would be great crushed up on top of ice cream or used in a peanut butter cake/pie-type recipe.
Final verdict? The Halloween Oreos are a fun change from the regular Oreos and I would definitely get them again. I liked the Peanut Butter Oreos, but probably not enough to buy a whole pack again.